Ask the Car People.SM


Looking for a compact sedan (Mazda3, Civic, Elantra, Impreza, Focus) - READ ONLY

19 messages,  Last post on Oct 03, 2012 at 9:10 AM

You are in the Hatchbacks - Archived Discussions Forum.

This discussion is ARCHIVED. To reactivate the discussion, post a request in the Lost? Ask the Hatchbacks Host for directions! discussion.

What is this discussion about? Mazda MAZDA3, Honda Civic, Hyundai Elantra, Sedan

Messages Page 1 of 2

#1 of 19 Looking for a compact sedan (Mazda3, Civic, Elantra, Impreza, Focus) by toonsngraphics

Sep 21, 2012 (5:45 am)

I have been test driving many cars in the last month or so, but need some feedback. The cars in comparison are: Hyundai Elantra Limited, Mazda3 Grand Touring Sedan, Subaru Impreza Limited Sedan, Ford Focus Titanium Sedan and the Honda Civic EX-L. I drove them all and thought they were decent driving cars. The Subaru Impreza is AWD which is probably not needed and dealer was not willing to move much at all from sticker so that one is probably out. The Hyundai Elantra seemed good but noticed blind spots while driving. Ford Focus I have heard has some possible transmission problems (is this true?), plus I have had Fords in the past and they have always been iffy cars. The Honda Civic and Mazda 3 both seemed like great candidates but now I hear the the Civic has many reliability and performance concerns for 2012 (which I was surprised for a Honda). Safecar.gov shows the Civic with 2 recalls, numerous technical service bulletins and many customer complaints. The Mazda 3 has no tsb, no recalls and few customer complaints, but now I've seen across the web that there may be transmission issues with the skyactiv auto tranny. Is this true also? Which car do you all recommend from this list or is there another I should consider? Thanks.

#2 of 19 Re: Looking for a compact sedan (Mazda3, Civic, Elantra, Impreza, Focus) [toonsngraphics] by autonomous

Sep 21, 2012 (11:01 am)

Replying to: toonsngraphics (Sep 21, 2012 5:45 am)
that there may be transmission issues with the skyactiv auto tranny
I thought there were issues were with the Skyactiv manual tranny, specifically transmission surges. I have not seen any issues related to the Skyactiv automatic.
 
By the way, the general recommendation from Consumer Reports is to avoid buying the first year of any new model of any car. This includes all of the manufacturers, including such trusted nameplates as Honda. The reason is quite obvious: to enable the manufacturer to work out the kinks found in the real world.

#3 of 19 Re: Looking for a compact sedan (Mazda3, Civic, Elantra, Impreza, Focus) [autonomous] by toonsngraphics

Sep 21, 2012 (11:04 am)

Replying to: autonomous (Sep 21, 2012 11:01 am)
I guess that would mean staying away from the Mazda 3 due to the new technology of the Skyactiv

#4 of 19 Re: Looking for a compact sedan (Mazda3, Civic, Elantra, Impreza, Focus) [toonsngraphics] by autonomous

Sep 21, 2012 (12:41 pm)

Replying to: toonsngraphics (Sep 21, 2012 11:04 am)
I guess that would mean staying away from the Mazda 3 due to the new technology of the Skyactiv
Yes, for the initial year.
 
As you know the Skyactiv technology has now been around for a year, and it appears to have proven itself in the automatic transmissions. Skyactiv manual transmissions are another story as they seem to be under a cloud at this point; I would investigate to see if their problems have been solved. Personally, I'd choose the next crop of Skyactiv automatics coming next month.
 
The Honda Civic was redesigned last year also. So, it would be worth looking at the commentary about the upcoming year to see if problem areas identified in TSBs, etc. persist.
 
Some auto manufacturers move very quickly to solve issues in the first year. For example, Toyota had an issue with its Camry automatics several years ago, and addressed this within the first few months.

#5 of 19 Re: Looking for a compact sedan (Mazda3, Civic, Elantra, Impreza, Focus) [autonomous] by backy

Sep 21, 2012 (1:14 pm)

Replying to: autonomous (Sep 21, 2012 12:41 pm)
FWIW the Impreza was newly redesigned for 2012, and the Focus is pretty new also and there have been many complaints about the automatic transmission. The Elantra is the "oldest" of these designs, but not by much, and if you like how the Mazda3 handles you might not like the Elantra so much--it has a smooth ride but handling is not sharp.
 
IMO the Jetta is worth checking out also. Although in a Jetta I favor a slightly used CPO pre-2011 Jetta vs the new one. But at least you wouldn't have the "new design" problem!

#6 of 19 Re: Looking for a compact sedan (Mazda3, Civic, Elantra, Impreza, Focus) [backy] by toonsngraphics

Sep 21, 2012 (6:42 pm)

Replying to: backy (Sep 21, 2012 1:14 pm)
With the mazda 3 it isn't really a new model it is an existing model with a new powertrain isn't it? Or does that still count as a new model? Plus, if I hold off till october (need a release date) then I loose the incentives mazda is giving on the 2012s. What to do? And still no word on hondas chages or release date.

#7 of 19 Re: Looking for a compact sedan (Mazda3, Civic, Elantra, Impreza, Focus) [toonsngraphics] by backy

Sep 21, 2012 (7:13 pm)

Replying to: toonsngraphics (Sep 21, 2012 6:42 pm)
Yes, you'll pay more for a 2013 Mazda3 right off the bat compared to the close-out 2012s.
 
What is your timeframe? Is there some compelling event that is forcing you to buy a car soon? If not, you could wait awhile to learn about the 2013 Civic and see what happens on the Mazda3 prices.

#8 of 19 Re: Looking for a compact sedan (Mazda3, Civic, Elantra, Impreza, Focus) [toonsngraphics] by toonsngraphics

Sep 22, 2012 (9:42 am)

Replying to: toonsngraphics (Sep 21, 2012 6:42 pm)
I either need to purchase a new car or put money into my current car. If I put money into my current car I won't be buying a new one any time soon. I think I would rather takerhat money and put it toward a new car. So I need to make a decision soon plus mazda incentives are over at the end of sept...if I go in the mazda direction.

#9 of 19 Re: Looking for a compact sedan (Mazda3, Civic, Elantra, Impreza, Focus) [toonsngraphics] by backy

Sep 22, 2012 (10:52 am)

Replying to: toonsngraphics (Sep 22, 2012 9:42 am)
I can't tell you what you should do, but here's what I would do if I were in your position (assumes the money needed for the old car is substantial, not just a few hundred bucks):
 
1) Determine my budget.
2) Create a short list of cars I have some interest in that fit my budget (looks like you did that already).
3) Test-drive those cars (looks like you did that), and narrow down the list to only those I would want to drive on a daily basis.
4) Put those cars in order of preference and start serious buying with dealers near me. If I get a great deal on car #1 from someone (and get offers from multiple dealers if possible), get that one. If not, move to car #2, etc.
 
One thing I would NOT worry a lot about is relative reliability. All new cars today are pretty reliable. There's something to be said with not buying a brand-new design the first year out of the gate, but I have done that several times in my life and regretted it only with a 1995 Mercury Mystique, which spent several days in its first few months at the dealer for various small problems. One advantage there of the Elantra is its long warranty, if there are problems.
 
Frankly, if I were buying a car now vs. next summer I'd be sorely tempted by the incentives on the 2012 Mazda3i Touring. I've seen those advertised for just over $16k in my area with current incentives. But I'd also look at the Focus, Elantra GT (I like hatches), and Golf (but there likely go for a slightly used CPO car and save some money). Impreza is nice also, but like you I don't know that I need AWD and I'd like to get a stick if possible--and the Impreza has a 5-speed MT that makes the car much noisier with lower fuel economy than with the CVT.

#10 of 19 Favorite car ever just traded in...get it while you can! by gr8mazda3

Sep 22, 2012 (12:47 pm)

I just had to trade in my 2008 Mazda3 GT not because I wanted to, but I had to due to health reasons. I can no longer safely operate a manual transmission safely due to back/left leg problems. The car has under 45k miles on it and I swear it was my favorite automobile I've ever owned/rented/driven, etc. For the money, there is no better vehicle on the road.
 
I do remember back in 2008 that finding a GT loaded out with a manual transmission was difficult, so if you are interested in such a car, it's for sale right now in East Tennessee and if you want details, respond to this post. I don't think it will last long, as it is copper red mica and everyone seems to love the car. I know I did, and I'll miss it. Getting used to my new 2012 Mazda 3 I Touring with SkyActiv engine and 6A. So far, it's very good, but it's a sad day for me to have to give up that slick manual for a slush box. Respond if interested in exact location of the car. Zoom zoom!

Messages Page 1 of 2

Advertisement

Browse by Category

Browse by Vehicle
   View All Vehicles

Browse by Board
Browse by Topic
View All Topics

Edmunds Community

Advertisement