Ask the Car People.SM


Best tire opinion for Malibu

14 messages,  Last post on Jan 10, 2010 at 5:01 AM

You are in the Chevrolet Malibu Forum.

What is this discussion about? Chevrolet Malibu, Safety Technology, Steering, Suspension, Tires, Sedan

Messages Page 2 of 2

#6 of 14 Re: Best tire opinion for Malibu [e_net_rider] by gonogo

Dec 31, 2009 (9:21 am)

Replying to: e_net_rider (Dec 31, 2009 5:59 am)
Maybe on this forum, the Malibu forum wants you to go away, you sure like to type,lol

#7 of 14 Re: Best tire opinion for Malibu [e_net_rider] by malexbu

Dec 31, 2009 (2:42 pm)

Replying to: e_net_rider (Dec 31, 2009 5:59 am)
Please do not listen to gonogo and stay. Your musings are interesting and are appreciated. Those who don't like them, can skip them. No one here has the privilege to send another away.

#8 of 14 Re: Best tire opinion for Malibu [malexbu] by gonogo

Jan 01, 2010 (8:04 am)

Replying to: malexbu (Dec 31, 2009 2:42 pm)
I never told him to go away, I just said he needed a hobby. The other Malibu forum got tired of his complaining and told him to sell his Malibu, then all his problems would be solved. He listed about 12 problems on that site, they got tired of it.

#9 of 14 Re: Best tire opinion for Malibu [gonogo] by e_net_rider

Jan 01, 2010 (9:04 am)

Replying to: gonogo (Jan 01, 2010 8:04 am)
Thanks Malexbu.
As you can see, there are some that are offended by any mention that a Malibu could have a problem, despite numerous other posts with many similar issues.
Sharing tire information was common in some of the other edmunds forums I've been in and was always appreciated. I know I appreciated it for one particular vehicle I owned because it saved me and many others hundreds of dollars when it came time to replace.
This tire issue just being one of several issues seemed to ignite a fuse when I posted that I had discovered that the tires that came on the car were not "Touring Tires" as stated on the window sticker.
Maybe some of the critics don't realize the difference between such ratings as passenger, touring, grand touring, winter, summer, or even truck tires. And definitely do not understand that even within a tire grouping what tire is great on one vehicle it might not have the same qualities on a different vehicle. And that is specifically whay I started a thread to learn others experience with different tires.
Certainly I expected "Touring Tires" as a starting point, even if they were not the best match for this vehicle.
And with other issues present, over in those GM formums it seemed like there were company men dedicated to quashing anything but praise for Malibu.
However,. there are some over there that truly seemed to help with good advice.
 
I would strongly suggest that the better forum to start in is Edmunds. Then if you run out of help, then maybe take a look at GM since there seems to be some dedicated mechanics over there, or do as I did, follow the suggestion here, Edmund forum, to check over there. It might not be a place for the thin skinned.

#10 of 14 Re: Best tire opinion for Malibu [e_net_rider] by malexbu

Jan 01, 2010 (7:41 pm)

Replying to: e_net_rider (Jan 01, 2010 9:04 am)
Maybe some of the critics don't realize the difference between such
ratings as passenger, touring, grand touring, winter, summer, or even
truck tires.
 
To be honest with you, I still don't realize that difference -- if you
could share your experience/opinion, I'd appreciate it.
 
We (you and I, in particular) briefly talked about tires a couple of
months ago and I said I could not, in honesty, distinguish between
various tires on my three Malibus. Since then, I changed the rear
tires on my Maxx -- the ones I bought it with were pretty worn out,
and, in the early November, I was almost thrown off the ramp entering
the highway. So, I installed the pretty expensive Eagle ComforTred
ones there, with the "20% extra padding". Did it make my pretty
road-sensitive Maxx smoother? A bit, undoubtedly. But not to the
extent that I could say it changed the nature of the car and the road
feel. Of course, I have no fear of losing the road grip now, but this
is simply because the old ones were so worn out. (The old tires were
"Cooper Lifeliner GLS", of wrong size, it turned out: P215/65R instead
of P215/60R16 supposed to be there (in that older discussion I
misidentified them as Continentals, IIRC).)
 
So, a direct question to you: what would be my experience if instead
of ComforTred, a "passenger" tire, I installed a touring or grand
touring one?
 
When you regret not getting "Touring Tires", what exactly you think
you are missing, other than the name?

#11 of 14 Re: Best tire opinion for Malibu [malexbu] by e_net_rider

Jan 07, 2010 (6:24 am)

Replying to: malexbu (Jan 01, 2010 7:41 pm)
My experience is that Touring Tires ride better and quieter than std passenger tire. Often tend to roll straighter and hopefully get rid of the slight vibration from the road surface. The next step up would be to Grand Touring Tires. Some are available in MS, multi season, or even winter versions.
But there are also other categories that might fit your needs such as Sport or High Performance. They may have higher speed ratings if you need that. Or better traction on dry surface. If you like to drive aggressively, say cornering at maximum speed they might suit better as well, but I don't drive that way because it would be easy to out drive visibility or encounter something on the road you weren't expecting. The best tires for such would likely still fall short if you encountered an oil patch.
If you are an aggressive sporty driver you might not mind that such tires are generally noisier and ride harsher.
I like a tire that will stay balanced, wear evenly, do its job well on wet roads, especially against hydroplaning, rides well but grips too, and is quiet. What might seem quiet on one vehicle could be noisy on another because of vehicle construction. Same goes for handling.
I think it was Tire Rack that used to have a way that you could search for your specific vehicle and then read the comments of users as to what their experience was with particular tires.
Sorry to hear the expensive tires did not give you a big boost. Sounds like you only gained because of new tread and that the old tires may have started getting hard with age.
I am going to start another thread about GM Tire Performance Criteria (TPC) and I'd like you to participate because you have more than one BU. It could yield some interesting results.
20% extra padding?

#12 of 14 Re: Best tire opinion for Malibu [e_net_rider] by e_net_rider

Jan 08, 2010 (8:08 am)

Replying to: e_net_rider (Jan 07, 2010 6:24 am)
Added insight. I was surprised at the numbers that came in for your tire.
I compare the reviewers as well as test results because the test results seem to all be from a BMW and I don't drive a BMW.
When looking at the test charts you might note that they only compare tires in the same grouping. Passenger tires with other passenger tires and the one I'm investigating, a grand touring with other grand touring. The one I'm interested in posted higher numbers for each test than the comfortread.

#13 of 14 Re: Best tire opinion for Malibu [e_net_rider] by malexbu

Jan 09, 2010 (8:15 am)

Replying to: e_net_rider (Jan 08, 2010 8:08 am)
I was surprised at the numbers that came in for your tire.
 
If you are talking to me, about Goodyear Assurance ComforTred, and
refer to the TireTrack reviews:
 
Look what you have there, on the scale of 1 to 10 -- just three reviews:
4.5, 8.7. 9.5.
 
I don't think any person with scientific or engineering background
will try to make a meaningful conclusions on the basis of that sample:
too small, too varying. Throwing away that 4.5 seems like a must, as
a "measurement error".
 
On the other hand that above number show that with the same tire the
assessment can vary wildly -- there is not objective metrics to
measure "the feeling".
 
When looking for a tire replacement this fall, I did read a lot of
reviews. That reading was useful in one sense -- to come not to
believe them. If you never drive the same car with different tires
with the similar mileage on them, you can't compare your tires with
others. I have three Bu's, all with different tires, and I think I
have a reasonable basis for judgement, and it is:
 
 * The tires may wear differently, but I will not know until they are
   done.
 
 * The tires are indistinguishable, in all practical ways, for a
   person with normal (for Bu) driving patterns. (FWIW, I usually
   drive in the left-hand lane).
 
ABS and traction control do make a difference -- one of my Bu's
doesn't have it, so I know.

#14 of 14 Re: Best tire opinion for Malibu [malexbu] by e_net_rider

Jan 10, 2010 (5:01 am)

Replying to: malexbu (Jan 09, 2010 8:15 am)
Actually you need to hit the reviews button and then filter by Chevrolet. That will yield 56 reviews and several are for Malibu. I'm not sure what that low score we saw was about. Maybe he had other problem with vehicle, grain of salt, and near 50K is not bad for a tire that performs under all conditions very well.
The test results are done by company, under tests button, and hoping they are a bit more objective than reviews, which are purely subjective. As stated earlier, to get tests for touring or grand touring you have to look up tests on that tire. The one I looked at in that category was the Michelin Primacy MXV4.
Where I run into a problem is that different sites show a different size as the OE for 17" wheels. Some say 215/55R17, others show 225/50R17 as the OE. Which is why I put up the survey for TPC. According to GM, the tests they do are to find the single best tire for your vehicle and that is the TPC of your OE tire (found on sidewall). So far I have not located a cross reference showing vehicles and what number or numbers apply. I did find a TPC to tire converter and it shows the tires I have, but many other owners seem to have come with a different tire, so how is it the single best?

Messages Page 2 of 2

To POST a message, please Sign In.

Advertisement

Browse by Category

Browse by Vehicle
   View All Vehicles

Browse by Board
Browse by Topic
View All Topics

Edmunds Community

Advertisement