Article Comments - Super Sedan Showdown

20 messages, Last post on Oct 25, 2009 at 11:48 AM

You are in the Cadillac CTS/CTS-V Forum. Your Hosts are pat & karens

What is this discussion about? BMW M5, Cadillac CTS-V, Mercedes-Benz E-Class, Car Comparisons, Sedan

Super Sedan Showdown - Is the 2009 Cadillac CTS-V a true benchmark in the super sedan category? Measured against the pure performance of the 2008 BMW M5 and the value of the 2009 Mercedes-Benz C63 AMG, we knew the truth would come out. (more)

Outline

Messages Page 2 of 3: 1; 2; 3; Prev; Next; Last

#4 of 20 Finally! Now was that so hard? by ne1butu2 Dec 02, 2008 (9:50 pm)
I never thought I'd see the day that a Cadillac would trounce the germans. I haven't driven the CTS-V, but I've driven the standard CTS. And I have to say that it's really good... maybe 95% there. The MB C63 is based on a marginal small sedan, has a cheap-o interior and an exterior with a goofy rear end. The 5-series is an ergonomic mess with interior styling derived from an ER. Visually, the 5's exterior carries itself like a cocky fat drag queen. So it begs the question, is the CTS-V good because it's really good? Or do I want one because these two Germans are so unappealing these days? I'm going to be anxious to see what the next RS-4 brings to the mix because I've pretty much written off MB and BMW.
#5 of 20 Re: Article Comments - Super Sedan Showdown [porschecarrera] by Seven59 Dec 03, 2008 (5:42 am)
Replying to: porschecarrera (Dec 02, 2008 4:15 pm) porschecarrera, 7:59 is a lap record for a production sedan. Obviously, there are many classes of vehicles that test and develop at the Nurburgring. Here is Cadillac's May 9, 2008 press release regarding the Nurburgring time: "2009 CTS-V Blisters Nurburgring. Breaks 8-minute barrier - potentially the fastest documented lap time for a production sedan In testing today at Germany’s Nurburgring, Cadillac’s upcoming new 2009 CTS-V completed a lap of the legendary Nordschleife in 7:59.32. This blistering time appears to be the fastest ever publicly documented for a production sedan." No other manufacturer has yet come out to challenge this statement.
#6 of 20 What about...? by sabastian Dec 03, 2008 (9:49 am)
I understand IL's logic in including the C63, but if you are going to test one of the smaller sport-sedans (that compete closer to its price point) against the CTS-V, why not include the M3 (which already beat the C63 in a comparison test). Sure, throwing the Caddy against two BMW's would have seemed odd, but I've seen the IL editors explain there way out of much weirder pairings (R8 vs Cherokee SRT-8 anyone?). The normal CTS has been compared with the 335i, so why not in this instance?
#7 of 20 by ahightower Dec 03, 2008 (2:49 pm)
"So there you have it. My favorite wasn't even in this test." Neither was mine. I'll take an M3 sedan with 6-speed manual.
#8 of 20 nice try by thom2 Dec 03, 2008 (8:02 pm)
Nice try to boost GM's reputation when the company is about to tumble. Looks like GM wants to do some back door dog barking to save some face, but unfortunately no one is buying it. Replies to this message: aintmisbehavin (Dec 05, 2008 5:43 pm) thom2 (Dec 06, 2008 6:21 am)
#9 of 20 Re: nice try [thom2] by aintmisbehavin Dec 05, 2008 (5:43 pm)
Replying to: thom2 (Dec 03, 2008 8:02 pm) blea blea blea, lick your wounds and tuck your tail. You got your doors blown again. Too bad they can build a car that will out perform your Euro sedans without breaking a sweat. Go Caddy, maybe that is why they are winning everything. Replies to this message: thom2 (Dec 06, 2008 6:21 am)
#10 of 20 Re: nice try [aintmisbehavin] by thom2 Dec 06, 2008 (6:21 am)
Replying to: aintmisbehavin (Dec 05, 2008 5:43 pm) those are not my sedans, i wish they are
#11 of 20 Re: It's all about the look.... [draw007] by lovecars5 Feb 06, 2009 (5:03 pm)
Replying to: draw007 (Dec 02, 2008 5:07 pm) Sorry go spend another 30k for the inferior car. Not to mention cost american workers their jobs!!!! good call. If you like germany so much go live there! Replies to this message: vic10 (Feb 11, 2009 1:01 pm)
#12 of 20 Re: It's all about the look.... [lovecars5] by vic10 Feb 11, 2009 (1:01 pm)
Replying to: lovecars5 (Feb 06, 2009 5:03 pm) I burst out laughing when I read draw007's post. Accusing the Caddy of being overpriced when comparing it to a MB, a German Chevrolet that's optioned out for the U.S market then priced for the gullible??