Last post on Dec 08, 2013 at 1:46 PM
You are in the Acura MDX
What is this discussion about?
Acura MDX, SUV
Go to NHTSA to file a safety complaint.
Or call Monday-Friday (8 am to 8 pm ET) (888) 327-4236 TTY: (800)424-9153
#513 of 996 Same problem...suggestions at this poinit?
Jan 28, 2011 (6:04 am)
So, we took our 2005 MDX (89K miles) for the Torque Converter recall about a month ago. After they "fixed it" we noticed it was still shuttering. So, we took it back to them and they REMOVED THE TRANSMISSION, replaced a few other things and the shutter went away. That was 3 weeks ago.
Today, I was driving and noticed the D5 light started blinking. In reviewing other internet posts, it can mean the transmission is going out or a switch is overheating/failing. I'm not experiencing any other problems so he said that it is probably the switch and that sometimes that happens when a transmission is removed and put back in. So, I took it into the Acura dealership today and they are currently looking into it. On the phone, I said "it wouldn't cost anything to get the switch replaced...right?" He went on to say well if you don't have the extended warranty, then yes. I'm going to fight this one for sure...they had to pull the transmission because of the torque converter recall....I'm sure that is what is causing it....it's just a coincidence that 3 weeks after they worked on the trasmission that now it the D5 light is blinking?
#514 of 996 The plot thickens
Jan 28, 2011 (7:17 am)
Well I had the ECU remap done and I could see the problem lessen but it was still there occasionally. Now, about 4 weeks later, I suddenly get a tapping and check engine light. Within a few hundred feet the all wheel drive light comes on as well. A quick OBD-II check shows a cylinder 4 misfire but the engine was just inspected and the oil changed by the Acura dealer who performed the ECU remap a few weeks prior. Honda/ Acura will get one shot at fixing this issue if it ends up being somehow related to the TC. If they don't I'm moving forward with a lawsuit. Enough is enough. They knew/ know there is a problem, denied it, then throw out some half-ass patches which only work, according to a manufacturer service manager about 1/2 of the time and still let this to continue.
Check out the FB page dedicated to this issue.
#515 of 996 Re: The plot thickens [wallabyguy]
Jan 28, 2011 (8:47 am)
If I bought the car in 2008 Certified Pre-Owned from Acura...wouldn't this be covered under the 7 year/100,000 mile powertrain warranty?
#516 of 996 Re: No permanent fix.... [dc1225]
Jan 29, 2011 (8:42 am)
"..1) there is no permanent fix..."
You could pull the fuses that power the drive to the rear clutches and dramatically extend the life of your transaxle. The other possibility is to put a switch in series with the power to the rear drive clutches and only power them under KNOWN low traction conditions.
#517 of 996 Re: No permanent fix.... [wwest]
Feb 01, 2011 (8:20 pm)
Dam WWest, who da hell know how to do that? Also, how do you know if that fixes it? How do you know if that messes with other parts of car function?
I had my TC replaced by dealership under waranty and PCM update. It lessened the shudder but the problem seems to be still there, just not as loud. Took it back week later because it was making minor shudder/whining/whistling noise and complaied to dealer and asked them to replace the entire transmission and they would not. They said they ran diagnostics on the tranny and they could not find nothing wrong. Also they said that its the bearings that's making the noise and its "normal" compared to other vehicles so they will not even open up the tranny to look at it. unreal
So this TC/Tranny problem is Normal guys according to my Acura dealership.
#518 of 996 What year MDXs have transmission problems?
Feb 02, 2011 (5:08 am)
Do all MDXs have transmission problems? I am looking to purchase a new midsize SUV with a third row (MDX, X5, LX470 or XC90). I see that there are major transmission issues with the MDX, particularly in the 2005/2006 models. Does anyone know if the 2010 or 2011 will have the same transmission issues? Has Acura fixed the problem? I have not been able to find this info anywhere.
Purchasing a car is overwhelming! It seems like all the cars have reliability issues. Any insight would be greatly appreciated.
#519 of 996 Re: What year MDXs have transmission problems? [motherof3inct]
Feb 07, 2011 (8:01 am)
Myself and several other 2010/2011 mdx owners are experiencing a slight metallic knocking noise in our vehicles at speeds between 0 - 25. Dealers cannot pinpoint the source of this issue. Someone that's a master tech at a forum mentioned that the noise is originating from the transmission. Dealers Acura/Honda are not being forthcoming if this is the case. Being in the situation I would not buy the mdx if I had to do it over again. But it may be something they can fix (pcm or knock sensor adjustment) Don't know.
Having a $60,000 vehicle that sounds like its got a diesel engine was not part of my plan. Not knowing what's causing the noise for months now has given me a bad view of Acura. I've also been told by the dealer that its normal for the car to sound this way. Yeah so Acura intentionally made a vehicle that knocks.
#520 of 996 Re: NEED YOUR THOUGHTS [sarj1]
Feb 07, 2011 (8:40 am)
Did you ever find out what was wrong with your tranny? I am having the exact same problem on my 2001 MDX with 152k miles on it. Please let me know what the dealer told you. my email is dtvo2005 gmail.com.
#521 of 996 Re: What year MDXs have transmission problems? [mdxtech2011]
Feb 07, 2011 (9:26 am)
During acceleration below 25MPH(20?) your "center diff'l" is locked, or at least partially so. On a highly tractive surface that will result in a LOT of undue stress on the drive train components. That stress level is often so high, say during a fairly tight accelerating turn, to the point that something MUST give.
In an actual 4WD in this situation it would most likely result in "tire hop"/scrubbing as a way to relieve the additional stress. In the early VTM-4 MDX that "give" was obviously provided by the torque converter (lockup clutch?) resulting in widespread premature failures of that component.
Your slight metallic knocking noise may be the result of slippage of whatever component, weakest link, must provide the required "give" when accelerating, even lightly, on a non-slippery, tractive, surface
Feb 07, 2011 (2:36 pm)
mother of 3, look elsewhere. Being mother of 3, this is headache that you do not need. I realize that all cars have problems but transmission/engine problems are the worst and most costly problems cars can have. You will not have a piece of mind owning an MDX. I'd lean toward X5 or RX350. I I believe BMW has 100k mile warranty now on power train, etc...Acura got rid of the 3rd row seat so all things being equal, X5 and RX350 comes out way ahead even if you have to pay bit more.