Article Comments - Ford Mustang Shelby GT vs. 2008 Subaru Impreza WRX STI

96 messages, Last post on Apr 18, 2008 at 4:24 PM

You are in the Subaru Impreza Forum. Your Host is kcram

What is this discussion about? Subaru Impreza WRX STi, Ford Shelby GT500, Car Comparisons, Sedan

Comparison Test: Ford Mustang Shelby GT vs. 2008 Subaru Impreza WRX STI - So why compare two cars whose target customers are so different? Well, first of all, they cost the same. The STI is slightly pricier at $39,440, only marginally more than the $39,180 Shelby. With as-tested prices within $300 of each other, the reality of cross-shopping these two on price alone isn't an arguable point. (more)

Outline

Messages Page 11 of 11: 1; ...; 5; 6; 7; 8; 9; 10; 11; Prev; Next; Last

#95 of 96 Re: WRX vs Mustang [waterdr] by waterdr Feb 23, 2008 (9:50 am)
Replying to: waterdr (Feb 23, 2008 7:00 am) Just so I am clear on a few things, I consider myself a car guy. I am not Ford person or do I owe loyalities to any manufacturer. I happen to own three cars and they are all of different makes. I buy what I like, what fits my needs, what I feel I can afford, and what makes sense to me. I think most owners probably do the same. I respect cars and I respect owners who love and are passionate about how they spend they hard-earned money, but I don't have to like it. Trends also change and quite frankly, as sustainability and "green" become more in style, this will also drive consumers to make different choices. Mustangs are WAY more popular or plentiful then a WRX. Why? Because people buy more of them. Maybe it is because people like them more. Perhaps it is because they cost less. The fact is that market factors are at play and Subaru has most likely chosen to go with the "less is more" concept with the STI to make sure that they can't be owned by everyone.....there is some advatanges of owning something that not everyone else has. A big appeal with a Mustang, however, is that no matter if you live in a trailer park or or mansion row, you will see them parked in driveways. If you go to a Mustang event, you will see hundreds....sometimes thousands of Mustangs on display. There are entire brick and motar businesses with thousands of acres of property that do nothing but work on them, restore them, and modify them. Many owners do the later because they want their cars to stand out in a sea of millions of cars that are essentially the same. All this results in a massive after-market driven by competition and hoards of expertise, though, not always sound. At least the STI is unique right out of the box, just not to my liking. I can't get past it. While I don't street race under any conditions, stop light to stop light, there is nothing better to launch especially when just two wheels are involved....provided the roads are dry - lol. The STI, on the other hand, to be honest, I would not be foolish enough even with my 450 hp car to want to get in a race on the curves with one. The two cars are very different indeed, different personalities, and sometimes different types of people behind the wheel. What is cool though, is having a community...one of people who can help other owners and defend your chosen set of wheels. I will promise you this.......I will drive one as soon as I can and I will then give you my opinion. If I find the car to be a joy, I will most certainly say so. If I still feel it is overpriced 3,000 lbs of plastic, then I will say so too.
#96 of 96 Why is my only question! by weeman04 Apr 18, 2008 (4:24 pm)
Why on earth would you compare and STI to a piece of junk Mustang? The Mustang is a heavy piece of junk V-8. Not even in the same class as an STI. Compare the STI to and EVO...9 or X. The Evo will pimp slap the STI in every aspect of the game! I wonder what the people at Edmunds was thinking when they did this comparison!!!