Ask the Car People.SM


Need a New Car for the Motion Sickness Prone!

11 messages,  Last post on Nov 07, 2012 at 12:11 PM

You are in the Sedans Forum.

What is this discussion about? Car Comparisons, Sedan

Messages Page 2 of 2

#2 of 11 Re: Need a New Car for the Motion Sickness Prone! [nathan118] by Mr_Shiftright HOST

Aug 21, 2007 (8:15 pm)

Replying to: nathan118 (Aug 21, 2007 4:18 pm)
I'm curious why you think the transmission has anything to do with your discomfort...could you elaborate?
 
I would think that you'd need a car with a very firm ride (very little body roll) and with very supportive seats that keep your body from moving side to side.
 
Actually a base model MINI sounds good for you, and it's right about $20K if you don't pile on the options. Of course, being a 2-door, using a car seat isn't so great.
 
Maybe something like a Scion xD or a Honda Fit might work for you...I'm thinking of cars that do not have a high center of gravity and aren't too tall, so that your head isn't moving too much (think of sitting at the top of the mast of a sailboat as opposed to sitting on the deck).

#3 of 11 Re: Need a New Car for the Motion Sickness Prone! [Mr_Shiftright] by nathan118

Aug 21, 2007 (8:42 pm)

Replying to: Mr_Shiftright (Aug 21, 2007 8:15 pm)
I've considered what you've said about the side to side movements, and this is certainly bigger than the '74 Ghia and '94 Celica.
 
I mention the transmission because in the Camry, unsmooth (and unexpected) acceleration and deceleration are a major cause of motion sickness. That's why being a passenger is so terrible, you can't anticipate starts and stops because you're not controlling the pedals.
 
I'd like something a little bigger than what you've suggested. My wife has an '01 Jetta and it works fine for me, so I'm looking at Jettas, Passats, Altima, Accord, even a Civic possibly. I'm not a big expert on the technologies behind the cars though, so anyone that knows more, feel free to chime in! Thanks.

#4 of 11 Re: Need a New Car for the Motion Sickness Prone! [nathan118] by gagrice

Aug 21, 2007 (9:08 pm)

Replying to: nathan118 (Aug 21, 2007 8:42 pm)
I would take the Jetta any day over the Camry. The transmission is much more positive. If you get the DSG it is like a manual without a clutch. Good luck.

#5 of 11 Re: Need a New Car for the Motion Sickness Prone! [nathan118] by pat

Aug 22, 2007 (6:54 am)

Replying to: nathan118 (Aug 21, 2007 8:42 pm)
Nathan, you might drop by the Midsize Sedans discussion and see what those folks think. Many of the cars you mention are the topic there.

#6 of 11 motion sick too by needsnewcar

Jan 27, 2011 (4:08 pm)

I have been test driving the smaller suvs after being in a sedan and feel sick as the driver!
Makes no sense to me...yesterday felt sick in a crosstour (not just cause of the price and style) someone suggested to me that it is the new aerodynamic slant to the windshields especially in people with glass others have said its the side motion in the suvs
Any thoughts and/or suggestions...looking for nice mix of awd and mpg willing to give up on the awd if I have to as I drive 25,000 plus a year, but I live in the woods.....thoughts?

#7 of 11 Re: motion sick too [needsnewcar] by nathan118

Jan 27, 2011 (6:42 pm)

Replying to: needsnewcar (Jan 27, 2011 4:08 pm)
I ended up with an 07 Jetta, and I love it. Amazing how different it drives than most of the cars on the market. I swear VW engineers them differently than everybody else. I even tried a Nissan with a CVT...and it still felt all mushy and non responsive.
 
I swear with the Jetta....I push the pedal and it goes, and I let off the pedal and it slows naturally. There's no weird downshifting like in the Camry, and it doesn't feel floaty. I love it.
 
In fact, I love it so much that I'd absolutely look at a VW in the future.

#8 of 11 Re: Need a New Car for the Motion Sickness Prone! [nathan118] by tabonifacio_95

Dec 01, 2011 (3:07 pm)

Replying to: nathan118 (Aug 21, 2007 4:18 pm)
Honestly I know exactly how you feel, I rode to Vegas many times and in some vehicles I'm 100% okay and in other's I'm just bleh out the window. The last time I actually had a comfy ride to Vegas was in an 05' Chevrolet Cobalt. Very firm, not floaty, but just a really enoyable ride. I now own a 95 Jeep Cherokee and it doesn't make me sick at all, Generally a higher more being able to see over everything makes a dramatic difference. I've had it from the day I hit the planet, Believe me I know it sucks.

#10 of 11 Re: Need a New Car for the Motion Sickness Prone! [tabonifacio_95] by csgirl

Nov 07, 2012 (12:04 pm)

Replying to: tabonifacio_95 (Dec 01, 2011 3:07 pm)
I have had the inner ear problem since a baby so I can relate. I also had a camaro and sold it fast as I could because I'd get so dizzy in that car ( not while driving....just when I would get out I would be staggering) that's my problem I get so carsick dizzy wise and no balance when we get out. I do pretty good in a truck that's high up, like a ford, or chevy the big z71 ect but my car I get even more sick. Here's the weird thing I road in a chevy trailblazer and got pretty sick oh and test drove a Buick rendezvous and got sick, is there something to this SUV thing? I thought maybe I needed to get away from a car into a truck what do you guys think?

#11 of 11 Re: Need a New Car for the Motion Sickness Prone! [csgirl] by nathan118

Nov 07, 2012 (12:11 pm)

Replying to: csgirl (Nov 07, 2012 12:04 pm)
For me, it hasn't been about car size...but the way the transmission shifts.
 
I recently test drove both passats...the standard and the TDI(diesel). The transmission in the TDI made me sick, but the standard was great.
 
For me it's about how the car drives. Does it go smoothly when I tell it to, and does it slow down smoothly when I let off the gas and break. If it starts aggressively downshifting on it's own...barf city.

Messages Page 2 of 2

To POST a message, please Sign In.

Advertisement

Browse by Category

Browse by Vehicle
   View All Vehicles

Browse by Board
Browse by Topic
View All Topics

Edmunds Community

Advertisement