Edmunds.com | Inside Line | Auto Observer Your Account | Help | Directory
You are here:
![[F]](http://a332.g.akamai.net/f/332/936/12h/www.edmunds.com/media/townhall/webxicons/site.gif){kind=small}
Forums
Sedans Acura TL New Acura TL vs Used Lexus GS
19 messages, Last post on Feb 22, 2009 at 7:01 AM
You are in the Acura TL Forum. Your Hosts are pat & karens
|
Replying to: dmeetri (Apr 20, 2007 12:50 pm)
|
|
|
|
|
Replying to: hauss (Apr 23, 2007 11:17 am)
|
|
|
|
|
Do you notice any significant difference in acceleration between the two cars.I have seen where people are saying that their V6 Honda feels faster than the GS350. I noticed the same phenomenon when I went from driving an ES 350 loaner to the GS 350. When I first drove the GS 350 I was expecting to be blown away by the extra 30 HP and was surprised that it didn't have that same sensation of power as the ES 350. Although I can't speak about the TL I can say that the ES 350 and the TL do have one thing in common: they're both front wheel drive vehicles. The torque steer on the ES 350 isn't really an issue per see but everytime I took from the light you can really hear the tires squeak if go full throttle. Also the power delivery feels spontaneous and if I had a clear light I could be at the next stop light by the time most people where at the intersection. It could also be a gearing issue as well the GS 350 doesn't seem to have the same power off the line. However once you do get going there certainly is potential to get into trouble in the GS 350. I think the mid band power delivery is smoother in the GS 350 than the ES 350. But there is an amazing thrill with ES 350 because you can get so much power so quickly , at least compared to my old car (IS 300). People say that the ES 350 is a glorified Camry and maybe it is but its still a very quick car off the line. Then again people would probably say the same thing about the TL. In fact I don't think most people would push an ES or even the sportier TL near its limits. Sure the GS 350 is better at true high speed driving at 80+ mph but the ES 350 won't let you down either and has remarkable composure at high speeds 80-90 mph in sweepers. But then again I image the TL would ultimately prove to be a sportier can in absolute terms. The GS 350 being a RWD car and sporting larger and softer tires has some incredible performance. Aside from the small tight corners the limits on the GS 350 are noticably higher than the ES 350 but those limits are so high that you really have to be interested in going outragously fast before they become an issue. If you really enjoy driving fast on sweeping roads and corners all the time I think the GS would suffer from less tire wear than either the TL or ES 350. However we are really talking about some very high speeds or windy roads or sweeping curves that most people will never have the courage to test. True you didn't ask about the ES 350 but I feel for the vast majority of drivers its really a more appropriate car thsm the GS 350. Its bigger has a roomier interior and has a wonderful sensation of immediate power. Although I haven't driven the TL I can tell you that ES 350 has more than enough performance for most people and its limits are both fairly high and readily accessible. Despite my experience in the IS 300 I feel like I'm still coming to grips with the GS 350 , yes its a fast car, but the limits are so high that it really does take time to get a feel for the GS 350. Also the GS 350 is not as forgiving as the ES 350,especially when you want to apply alot of power very suddenly during a turn at lower speeds. Lol its probably just a bad habit that I developed in my IS-300 and previous experience with FWD vehicles. However on high speed corners the GS 350 is truly composed and fairly forgiving. Although I can't be sure I would imagine that TL would probably be a better vehicle for tight corners. |
|
|
Replying to: billyperks1 (Apr 24, 2007 6:37 am) As for which vehicle to get that's a personal choice. If you like a sportier firmer ride then get a used '04-'06 TL (base '07 TL is more compliant - models with 6MT are even sportier) or even an '07 TL-S. If you like a refined, ultra quiet, smooth ride get the GS350. IMO, both cars are stunners to look at with the TL being sportier and the GS being more luxurious. The current rumor is that the 4th gen TL won't be out until fall of '08 as an '09 MY. That 17-18 month wait might be more than you're willing to hold out.
|
|
|
|
|
To be honest the GS350 is the primary vehicle for my fiance and not myself. If that's the case then I would probably opt for a TL or Lexus ES 350, with an emphasis on the E 350 since it has lots of space so a woman can carry her things and friends around. When I bought my Lexus IS 300 my sister got a one too, it was the wrong vehicle for her. She doesn't enjoy driving fast so she was never able to use it her advantage. Being a hard braker she burned through her brakes faster than I burned through mine and sometimes upset the car. She also hates the soft compounds that her IS 300 uses because she has to replace the tires more frequently. Also rear wheel drive vehicles can be very unforgiving in low traction conditions and during improper application of the brakes or throttle. It takes more attention to properly operate a RWD vehicle and more things can go wrong if the driver isn't up to par. Although I haven't driven the TL I would imagine that its probably lower and has a harsher ride than the ES 350. Sure you or I can appreciate that but I seriously doubt that most women would. But the TL is probably smaller so its probably easier for most women to manuver around tight spaces in traffic or parking structures. I feel that most women just don't have the same level visual perception that men do in tight spaces. Women though can be very silly. My sister passed up an oppurtunity to get an ES 300 even though it was by far a better car for her because the car didn't look "nice". My friend's wife wants a G35 because it looks cool, even though I think her safety would probably be compromised in a sport RWD high powered platform. Get her something that won't bite back and can carry her stuff and friends in style. That's my advice. What she wants and needs in a car is very different from what you want. Me personally I am happy with my GS 350 but if I had a fiance I certainly would be wary about getting her one because it can bite back hard in the wrong hands.
|
|
|
|
|
Replying to: hauss (Apr 25, 2007 10:01 am) |
|
|
Replying to: mefistofeles (Apr 25, 2007 11:53 pm) As for which vehicle is easier to manuever in tight spaces that would be the GS easily. It's RWD layout gives it a tigher turning radius than the FWD TL. Also, these vehicles are in the same size class (Mid) and are virtually indentical in size externally and internally. The GS350 is 190" long and the TL is 189.3" long. Inside the GS has more front seat space, a smaller back seat, and less headroom than the TL. IMO, the TL and GS350 are not really comparable as they are designed for different purposes. |
|
|
Replying to: dmeetri (Apr 19, 2007 6:33 am)
|
|
|
Replying to: addams (Feb 11, 2009 7:11 am) 
|
|
| I'd take AWD over FWD in any weather. | |
You are here:
Forums
Sedans Acura TL New Acura TL vs Used Lexus GS
New? Join Now!
Forum Tools
Search Forums
Browse by Vehicle
2010 Acura TL
2010 Lexus GS 350
Browse by Board
Browse by Topic
Today's Chats
