Last post on Aug 25, 2013 at 8:47 AM
You are in the Subaru Impreza Maintenance & Repair
What is this discussion about?
Subaru Impreza, Brakes, Sedan, Wagon
#35 of 68 Re: break switch is the problem [impreza2008]
Apr 30, 2008 (5:14 pm)
After a couple of months the brake switch problem returned tonight.. right after I released the brake pedal.. maybe the new break switch failed again..
If anyone has a repeat failure please write in. I also have difficuty shifting out of Park now.. I think its related to the brake switch failure.
Sol Briks 203-767-0770
#36 of 68 Re: break switch is the problem [impreza2008]
Apr 30, 2008 (7:24 pm)
I had the same problem re not being able to get out of park. When my break switch was fixed the transmission problem went away. I am very interested as to what your dealer says about this issue. I have not had the problem again but am now worried that I could in the future.
Would it be possible for you to keep us informed about the issue? Peggy Manner
#37 of 68 Re: break switch is the problem [mom3peggy]
May 01, 2008 (6:31 am)
Makes perfect sense. The brake switch is what is used to keep the car in P so if it has failed, then it wil not come out of P.
#38 of 68 Re: break switch is the problem [paisan]
May 02, 2008 (11:01 am)
I just had the second break switch replaced at Dan Perkins Subaru.. they think the design is flawed and may break again. At least they promised a free oil change the next time it happens.. very nice people.
Also, they spray painted the black peeled paint on the muffler.. which they damaged when they applied the paint harder.. see my other problem...
All in all the issues are being handled and I am happy with my 2008 Impreza.
PS...Does anyone have an opinion about the 2009 Forester?
#39 of 68 Re: break switch is the problem [impreza2008]
May 02, 2008 (12:47 pm)
Did your dealer indicate that they have had alot of problems with regard to the brake switch? I had the same problem and my dealer indicated that they have had only one other car with the same problem.
After I read about your second go around I called Subaru 's 800 number and asked if they have had a run of brake switch problems with the 2008 impreza. I was told no. They assured me that if there is a rash of warranty repairs for the brake switch something will be done about the problem.
Was your repair reported as a warranty repair? Do you think that your dealer reported their thoughts to Subaru re the design flaw? I realize that replacing the brake switch is not hard or expensive but I do not relish my new car having to be repaired every couple of months.PM
#40 of 68 Re: break switch is the problem [mom3peggy]
May 02, 2008 (4:55 pm)
I did not speak to the service manager.. just the counter person in the service department. She said they replaced the switch with the same type and they expected the same result in a few months. She had a theory of what was wrong with the design but I did not pursue it with her. She also said the next time this happens I will get a free oil change. I called my wife and said I should be getting lots of free oil changes.
Yes, this was a warranty repair. I was told to expect a survey from Subaru. I will see if there is a write in part to the survey so I can voice my displeasure. We priced out a 2009 Forester. I put that purchase on hold until I gain more confidence in Subaru quality.
I will report on this issue if another break switch failure develops. I know where the switch is located in case it does not reset. I may have to give it a whack to snap it back so I can get my transmission out of Park.
#41 of 68 Re: break switch is the problem [impreza2008]
May 12, 2008 (3:53 pm)
Guest what, yesterday the VDC and ABS lights came again on after I applied the brakes on the highway. I won't call the dealer until I need to go in for an oil change.. and hopefully collect on the pomise of a free oil change if the repair fails again.
I responded to a a survey sent by Subaru. Explained the repeated failures. Hope they email me and offer an explanation.
Please write in an let me know if you are having this problem.
#42 of 68 Re: break switch is the problem [impreza2008]
May 13, 2008 (6:18 am)
I am so sorry for all your problems.
Are your brakes still working and it is only the lights that are failing? Are you still having problems getting your car out of park? Hopefully you will not be buying the 2009 car.
Do you think the car is safe to drive?
#43 of 68 Re: break switch is the problem [mom3peggy]
May 13, 2008 (6:30 am)
The brakes work fine. The car is safe but the VDC, ABS and cruise control stop working. The first time this happened was in the winter while I was on ice. I pulled of the road.. carefully.. and restarted the car. In this weather I don't bother to reset because I am more concerned about having difficulty getting out of park.
When I started the car the next morning in my driveway all was well.. went out of park ok and the VDC and ABS lights reset. I dont know what is the point of getting the brake switch replaced if they put in the same design.. and within days the problem comes back.
#44 of 68 abs+vdc lights
May 14, 2008 (5:35 am)
Same problem I have on F2.5XT 4EAT, ABS and VDC lights coming on. Nothing found on the computer test. Should i suggest to Subaru service here to replace the breack switch as well?