Last post on Nov 19, 2006 at 5:55 PM
You are in the Hatchbacks - Archived Discussions
This discussion is ARCHIVED. To reactivate the discussion, post a request in the Lost? Ask the Hatchbacks Host for directions! discussion.
What is this discussion about?
Mitsubishi Eclipse, MINI Cooper, Convertible, Hatchback
#4 of 5 Re: 2007 Eclipse GT or 2006 mini cooper S [hockeyfreak4]
Nov 19, 2006 (1:11 pm)
I sell Mitsubishi's at Planet Mitsubishi in Modesto, Ca. I feel the Eclipse is the better buy. I am not trying to be partial, however the Eclipse is well made and easier to get.
#5 of 5 Re: 2007 Eclipse GT or 2006 mini cooper S [sharice]
Nov 19, 2006 (5:55 pm)
Hard to be impartial if you're selling them...
As for reliability, the 2006 Mini is now on the recommended list for CR. As for a better buy, it depends on what you're after. I own both a Mini and a Mitsubishi; I like the Mitsubish, but I love the Mini. The Mini has much more personality than the Eclipse--the Eclipse is a great looking car, but the Mini gets second looks/comments like no other car I've owned (I could actually do without some of that). I would definitely say the Mini is better made than the Mitsubishi, from my experience. Fit/finish was much better (I bought both cars brand new) on the Mini.
Mitsubishi offers a good value--you'll be hard pressed to get a Mini less than MSRP, not so Mitsubishi--but one of my concerns with Mitsubishi is if they'll even be around in a few years. The company is doing less than stellar, and the upcoming models may be make or break with them. There is a reason the Eclipse is easier to get--it's not as high in demand. This will come into play when it time to sell it; the Mini is going to depreciate less.
As for tuning, the Mini can be tuned relativiely easily, but it's not a DYI job--but there are many different places you can go to improve performance. This isn't a major concern though for most people.
In the end, these are very, very different cars, and you're going to have to determine what your priorities are. The Mini S is a quirky, sporty hot hatch; it offers outstanding performance (I chuckle a little bit at the "Nerdy Cute" line; anyone who's seen a well driven Mini at the track or in autocross probably would debate that description); the Eclipse is closer to a true sportscar; it's not as much of an attention getter as the Mini, and it's a bit more conventional in appearance, although it's a great looking car (I've always been a fan of the Mitsubishi look), and has more of the modern sportscar look (I won't argue for the price that the Eclipse isn't a good deal--it's alot of car for the money. The Mini is also a good car for the money though--BMW is not making much money on the current generation of Mini, even selling at MSRP. It won't be until the new generation of Mini that BMW will make anything worthwhile from a profit standpoint). Although the Mini is small, with the seats down it offers a fair amount of storage space. The backseats for passengers though are almost worthless--I'd look elsewhere if you're going to use this as taking more than one other passenger.