Ask the Car People.SM


Honda Accord vs. Toyota Camry vs. Volkswagen Passat

1838 messages,  Last post on Apr 26, 2010 at 5:30 PM

You are in the Volkswagen Passat Forum.

What is this discussion about? Honda Accord, Toyota Camry, Volkswagen Passat, Sedan

Messages Page 2 of 184

#11 of 1838 Transmission Problems by hiflyer

Aug 07, 1999 (5:35 am)

The transmission in my former '94 Integra shook the entire car when shifted into reverse. It was all right once underway, but still didn't shift as well as I liked on a number of occasions. The dealer passed it off as being typical. Probably the worst thing about that car.

#12 of 1838 Hate to bring up other cars, but... by sv1

Aug 07, 1999 (5:57 am)

I just test drove the 4 cylinder Galant. I think you should to. 4 years/0% financing means you'll save a couple thousand of the bat compared to the Camry or Accord. And, believe it or not, you'll swear you're driving a 6.


The brakes are horrible, though. Otherwise, great car. Very quiet, very smooth. Great engine/transmission. Plenty of power. (Talking about the 4.) Definetely worth checking out.


I was offered about $17.4K with the 0% financing. So, to give you an idea, the Galant ES will cost you about $17.5K.


There's a $1250 rebate, but then no financing. If you choose to take the rebate in lieu of the financing, cost goes down to $16,250. Pretty good value.


Plus, you're buying Japanese, just incase you have problems with American cars. (I don't. I just bought one today.)

#13 of 1838 . by sv1

Aug 07, 1999 (5:59 am)

I should say, "to give you an idea, the Galant should cost you about $17.5K max." Unless it was sitting on the lot for long.

#14 of 1838 . by hondabro98

Aug 07, 1999 (7:10 am)

Why buy an inferior Jap car like the Galant for $17,500, when you can buy the best mid-size Jap car like the Accord LX automatic for $15,900?

#15 of 1838 . by hondabro98

Aug 07, 1999 (7:17 am)

hyflier,


  I had a '95 Integra and NEVER had the problem you described. The only transmission problem I could notice was during acceleration: when I lift my foot off gas then depress it again, there would be a huge hesitation. But that seem typical as other owners have said the same thing.

#16 of 1838 . by sv1

Aug 07, 1999 (2:35 pm)

KYBOAR-PROBLMS


you-kan-not-buy-an-akor-for-15.9k.

#17 of 1838 hondabro98 by hiflyer

Aug 07, 1999 (3:51 pm)

Well just accept the fact that it ALWAYS did in my case (re: post #10). That year the Civics were recalled for transmission problems. I suspected the same problem with my Integra, but Acura refused to acknowledge such a thing.

#18 of 1838 passat13 by passat13

Aug 07, 1999 (10:47 pm)

I drove an 88' legend I had a problem with the transmission jerking everytime it would shift gears(auto). Then I bought a 93' Legend and it had the same problem. I spoke to the dealer and he told me that all Hondas and Acuras have that problem after they reach a certain mileage. I would definitely go with the VW. That's what I will be purchasing in about 1 week.

#19 of 1838 Toyota Camry: 4 vs. 6; traction control by claudial

Aug 08, 1999 (3:30 am)

OK, I read enough about the Honda's transmission problems and the Passat's electrical problems to convince me to go with the Camry. Two questions:


1. I'm getting an automatic. I test drove the 4 cyl and it felt fine. Am I missing something and would I regret not getting the 6 cyl?


2. What is traction control and do I want it?


Thanks.

#20 of 1838 carbuff by rph74

Aug 08, 1999 (6:02 am)

     I just bought a 99 Accord EX 4 door with 5- SPEED last December. I highly recommend the 5- Speed for its smoothness and quick acceleration, although I'm dissapointed that the gas mileage is roughly the same as automatic (according to EPA figures). I also looked at Jetta and Passat, but I am wary of their reliability record. Why else would they have a 10 year warranty, unless their past products have been unreliable? Chances are, transmission and engine problems are the last things you will have to worry about, take it from me, a guy who has owned his share of used cars with high mileage! Little things like, A/C, accessories(ie fuel and water pump), and electrical problems are what will get you. Hyundai also just came out with a 10 year powertrain warranty, and they have a really bad reputation for reliability. Anyway, I really love my Honda, it feels really solid, and is very comfortable. For less than 20,000 (if you negotiate well) you get power sunroof, power windows and locks, alloy wheels, cd player, just about all the toys one needs!!!! It's easier to deal with an Accord simply because Honda's do not have options!! You either get Ex, Lx or DX, that's it. The other cars can get a little more confusing! I have never heard of this auto. transmission problem before I read this message board, but it sounds like something to check out. If it looked a little better, I would recommend the Toyota Camry. If you want to buy a Camry, look for one that was built in Japan. Seems as though half the ones I've seen are built in Kentucky. It's just my opinion, but Japanese cars were better when they were built in Japan, I think they have workers with a harder work ethic, and more attention to detail than we Americans. In conclusion, Camry is better if you want a quiet ride, Passat is better for sportiness, and the more enthusiastic driver (who doesn't mind spending extra on repairs!) and the Honda is somewhere in the middle, and a little easier to find one with the options that you need!!!

Messages Page 2 of 184

To POST a message, please Sign In.

Advertisement

Browse by Category

Browse by Vehicle
   View All Vehicles

Browse by Board
Browse by Topic
View All Topics

Edmunds Community

Advertisement