Last post on Oct 21, 2007 at 5:54 PM
You are in the Honda Civic
What is this discussion about?
Honda Civic, Toyota Corolla, Sedan
#65 of 199 Corolla LE 2005
Sep 04, 2004 (4:18 am)
Hi I too was in the market to buy a car. I went for the 2005 Toyota Corolla LE.
My brother bought a 2004 Honda Civic EX back in January of '04 the car is nice and I like it alot. Both my parents, and my brother said that I should get one too.
Before I bought the Corolla I had a 1990 Acura Integra which I still have. "My husband is driving it now" It has a few minor outside problems, but It has 83,000 miles so there was no point in selling it I would not have gotten anything for the car. It is still driving good needs a little work. I also have emotional attachment to the car it is a family air loom. This car has been in the family since I was 13 years old I am now almost 28. I guess it was about time I got something new right.
I have driven in my brother's car(04 civic ex) many times and I like it I like the look the ride. But when I test drove the 05 Corolla I was in love. I Love the way it looks " Very Classy looking. The car looks great in silver" It was roomier on the inside than the civic the ride was much smoother "It rides like a luxury car but it could catch up to the sporty cars I call it my baby lexus."
The mpg is incredible "I only fill up once a week", and the price was around $2000 less than what my brother paid for his car.
Whatever car you buy wether it is a Honda or Toyota you will be getting great car that will last for years but to make that final choice test drive and ask people who own cars like these now on how they like it.
#66 of 199 Edmunds forums needs reform!
Sep 05, 2004 (8:02 pm)
My family is also planning to buy a compact car and I have been given the task of researching. I thought this discussions might help because we would rather buy brand names known for quality namely toyota and honda rather than newcomer like kia. Not that I don't appreciate all the comments found here, but the way I look at it is, there is a bunch of guys who like the civic, there is a bunch of guys who like the corolla, there is a bunch that notes the pros and cons of each, and last but not least there is a bunch that don't know. I think it might be easier to add a poll option here like most online forums to help confused buyers like me.
#67 of 199 Re: Edmunds forums needs reform! [zup]
Sep 06, 2004 (3:54 am)
Well another thing that made me decide to get the toyota was that it was a little cheaper in insurance
#68 of 199 Re: Edmunds forums needs reform! [zup]
Sep 06, 2004 (10:41 am)
If you relied on a poll to make your decision, you'd have "the guys who like the Civic" voting for the Civic and "the guys who like the Corolla" voting for the Corolla, and you wouldn't have the benefit of being able to read and evaluate for yourself the reasonings they give for their opinions.
Certainly you are entitled to your preferences, but I'd a lot rather read about why someone thinks what he or she thinks than just the results of an either/or choice presented to people who don't have to back up their choice with some kind of reasoning.
Just my thoughts.
#69 of 199 Re: 2004 Honda Civic LX vs. 2004 Toyota Corolla LE [blueiedgod]
Sep 06, 2004 (2:26 pm)
Unfortunately, that's the lowest quote I could get here in Ohio and I have no other choice. The Internet Manager was very straightforward and gave me a breakdown upon request. The sales tax from my county is outragously high.
BTW, anybody from Columbus Ohio should stay away from Direct Autoplex (Toyota, Scion, Mazda). Went to test drive a Corolla over the weekend based on the 'invitation' of the Internet Manager; looking for him he's nowhere to be found. Another salesperson tried to 'earn' my business for the day. I asked twice for the price of 2005 Corolla S and the breakdown (tax, title, fees), but seemed to be ignored. The salesperson came back with monthly payment plan for 60 months way over what a Honda Internet Manager quoted me for a 2004 Civic LX out of the door.
I sensed something very fishy about the dealership, especially because the salesperson's facial expression changed from nice and smilling to very stiff after I demanded him to tell me the price of a Corolla S with no options installed. When I said my budget is way below that, he kept asking me how much was I willing to pay. I was so uncomfortable with the whole experience so I gave him a number that I knew his Manager wouldn't be able to match (though still reasonably in the range quoted by Honda on a Civic LX). I waited for 10 minutes before the salesperson came back and said he'd be in touch with the Internet Manager (who 'invited' me for the test drive) to contact me. It's such a ridiculous experience so when I got home I emailed the Internet Manager that I'm considering a different vehicle altogether. Wish I can report this to Toyota but again will Toyota care about this?
#70 of 199 Re: 2004 Honda Civic LX vs. 2004 Toyota Corolla LE [zaza]
Oct 01, 2004 (10:36 pm)
I know how you feel. I was not impressed with the Toyota dealers here. Honda was very straightforward and I got a great deal on a Civic LX. Actually I will be making my final decision tomorrow. I will visit Toyota first to give them one last chance to earn my business. (I do like the Corollas but the nonsense of having to take side airbags w/ABS is baloney).
I actually e-mailed toyota at gotoyota.com (or toyota.com) and the options are separate but 'geographical considerations' have more packaging...Well I wrote them to let them know they gave me no choice but to go w/Honda...(I know I have not yet decided, but it's 95% certain).
#71 of 199 I dont follow
Oct 02, 2004 (6:46 am)
Why is ABS and side curtain airbags an issue? Those are two incredibly important safety features, and for 2005 the Civic continues to be unavailable w/ side curtains. Additionally, the only way to get ABS in a Civic is to buy the EX, which is often more expensive than you can find a Corolla LE w/ABS and Side Curtains... since the LE can be had without the Civic's standard alloys and moonroof, for example...
Oct 02, 2004 (6:56 am)
I would suspect cost and the preference to sell the higher profit models, and at higher percentages.
I, for one am glad the choice is there. If you plan to keep your vehicle more than 10 years, the air bags have a 10 year cinderella/cinderfella stroke of midnight clause. I am sure you'd be amazed at how much it will cost if you follow the recommendation to replace it.
In regards to ABS, while conceptually a good idea, falls far far short of its intented goals. When the ABS first came out, even the insurance company (I presume did the projective studies) came out and gave a ABS discount; citing safer, cheaper, less accidents, yada yada. Not too many years later (two as I recollect) they categorically cancelled the discount; citing words to the effect; "no statistical significance in decreasing accidents and fatalities (fulfilling the stated goal) !!??
Also most folks who would swear by them, really don't even know that the intented purpose is to be able to STEER while so called executing "panic stop like" applications. In just about 650,000 miles, the only time that I personally have the ABS work is when I take them out to PURPOSELY function them. 1. to make sure it works 2 keep in practice.
The reason why you want to keep in practice is that 1. abs does NOT overcome the laws of physics 2. keep one confident in how you and it will behave under emergency conditions. So what % of folks do you know do this??
#73 of 199 Corolla is more refined than Civic
Oct 04, 2004 (9:50 am)
I just bought a Corolla S over the Civic EX. I tried both a few times, and the biggest difference I noticed was the smooth ride and solid feel of the Corolla over the Civic. The difference was substantial.
The Civic feels like a tin can versus a Corolla. 1. Shut the doors on the Civic and it sounds like you crushed a soda can. Shut the doors on the Corolla and they close with a soft, sound insulated, reassuring thud.
2. Ride around in the Civic and hit bumps, and the car feels very light and a bit bouncy. The Corolla soaks up bumps with a much quieter, insulated cabin, and smooth ride.
3. Add to that the fact that most Corollas can be had for less than the Civic EX, and the hands down winner is the Corolla.
Oct 04, 2004 (10:28 am)
I am glad you had a good experience!I shopped between a Toyota Corolla and Honda Civic. In words, the Corolla is like a mini Camry. To me, the Civic was far away the better deal.
Also using Edmunds.com and local research indicated the Civic depreciated FAR less than the Corolla.