Ask the Car People.SM


Selecting and Buying My First Car

772 messages,  Last post on Sep 05, 2011 at 4:40 AM

You are in the Smart Shopper Forum.

What is this discussion about? Car Buying

Messages Page 77 of 78

#753 of 772 Re: First time car buyer--Need sugguestion pls!! [paul_devil] by kirstie_h HOST

Jul 31, 2007 (11:00 am)

Replying to: paul_devil (Jul 31, 2007 10:26 am)
You'll probably find it helpful to visit our MINI Cooper group. We have several active discussions about the vehicle, and some on problems/maintenance/repair issues as well. Most of the posts there will be from those who own the vehicle, so you'll see positive & negative owner experiences.

#754 of 772 Re: First time car buyer--Need sugguestion pls!! [kirstie_h] by bodble2

Jul 31, 2007 (6:03 pm)

Replying to: kirstie_h (Jul 31, 2007 11:00 am)
I think Pat had just bounced him over from the MINI group.

#755 of 772 Grand Cherokee vs Cherokee vs Pathfinder vs. 4Runner (First-time purchaser) by jayd123

Jul 31, 2007 (11:21 pm)

I am graduating and buying my first car would appreciate some advice:
    
I am considering purchasing an '03 or '04 model (max. purchase price is 20K) of the Cherokee, Grand Cherokee, Pathfinder, or 4Runner (also thinking Volvo XC90) models. If my primary concerns are reliability in regards to repairs (since the models are 3-4 years old) and mileage because I am moving to Los Angeles, what do you advise me on?
    
Also, how important would it be to buy from a dealer versus private party and should I spend the extra money to get a lower mileage vehicle still under manufacturer warranty?
    
Any advice would be much appreciated.

#756 of 772 Re: Grand Cherokee vs Cherokee vs Pathfinder vs. 4Runner (First-time purcha by asafonov

Aug 01, 2007 (6:57 am)

Replying to: jayd123 (Jul 31, 2007 11:21 pm)
None of the truck(let)s you listed are really fuel-efficient. The Grand Cherokee (did they even produce the original Cherokee in 03?) has spotty reliability; the Nissan and the Toyota are generally very reliable, especially the latter.
 
What is missing from your request for information is how you will be using the vehicle. I am assuming you will commute to work/business, since you have graduated. How long the commute? Streets or freeway? (though I understand in LA a lot of freeway traffic is stop-and-go)
 
Basically, you should articulate why you want a used SUV vs. a new sedan/wagon for the same price. Towing needs?
 
If I were you, I'd get a new Accord/Mazda[3,5,6]/Altima, or a new RAV4/CRV if you must have a higher seating and more cargo room.

#757 of 772 Re: First time car buyer--Need sugguestion pls!! [bodble2] by kirstie_h HOST

Aug 01, 2007 (6:59 am)

Replying to: bodble2 (Jul 31, 2007 6:03 pm)
LOL, that happens sometimes. Well, by checking out this topic & the MINI discussions, he should get some really good feedback!

#758 of 772 Re: Grand Cherokee vs Cherokee vs Pathfinder vs. 4Runner (First-time purchaser) [jayd123] by qbrozen

Aug 01, 2007 (8:18 am)

Replying to: jayd123 (Jul 31, 2007 11:21 pm)
I agree with asafonov. ESPECIALLY since you are concerned with mileage and ESPECIALLY since you are moving to LA, you should carefully consider your need of an SUV.
 
By the way, I'm pretty sure you won't be finding an XC90 for $20k unless its really miled up.

#759 of 772 Re: Grand Cherokee vs Cherokee vs Pathfinder vs. 4Runner (First-time purchaser) [jayd123] by ateixeira

Aug 01, 2007 (8:58 am)

Replying to: jayd123 (Jul 31, 2007 11:21 pm)
Every person I know that owned a Grand Cherokee ended up calling it a lemon. My former roommate's step mom, a high school buddy, and a college buddy all had terrible problems and would never buy another Jeep.
 
The Cherokee was a good design for 1984 when it came out, but by the 90s it was simply outdated.
 
Pathfinder - careful here, the later ones that got the 240hp version of the VQ engine need premium fuel. Imagine using lots of gas and expensive premium fuel at that. The earlier models didn't have much HP, so I'd pass on these, too.
 
4Runner is reliable, but not fuel efficient. And they hold their value well, so you'll pay more for them up front.
 
Volvo XC90 is expensive and so are the parts to keep it going. TCO may be the highest of the bunch, and that's mostly because it's in a higher class than the others.
 
Honestly? Try a 4 cylinger Highlander, perhaps. Or try smaller SUVs like the Forester, RAV4, CR-V. Newer Escapes are actually reliable and they depreciate quickly so that might be an option.
 
I drove a '98 Forester for 9 years and loved it. Life time MPG average was 25.1mpg on cheap old regular fuel, none of the SUVs you mentioned would even come close. Zero break downs.
 
Come to think of it you could buy a brand new Forester X for $19k and get the full warranty and everything.
 
We needed more space for the family so we got a van, but I miss it enough that we may buy a 2009 model when those come out.

#760 of 772 Engine Fluids Color and Rust questions by lhy

Jun 08, 2009 (4:46 am)

I have some questions about inspecting a used car.
 
I recently checked out a 1997 Honda Accord EX with 119K and an automatic transmission. The dealer is asking $4000 for it with a 3-month/3K powertrain warranty. At face value, this seems like a very good deal, but I have some questions about the car.
 
- How important is the color of the transmission fluid and oil?
 
The tranny fluid was a dirty brownish-pink and the oil was somewhat darkish brown-black. I know that transmission fluid should be pink in color and the oil should be light brown.
 
How concerned should I be about this? Does this indicate serious problems with the transmission and engine or just that the transmission fluid and oil haven't been changed recently?
 
- Another thing that I noticed about the car was there was some rust issues in the engine compartment--particularly small patches of rust under the hood and on some of the engine components/case.
 
The dealer said that the rust was only on the surface of the engine, but is this issue something that I should be concerned about?
 
This Accord is a one-owner car that was driven in the Northeast. The car seems a bit rough in appearance for a one-owner though. The rear power window was having problems working. Some of the trim was coming off, and there were some cosmetic issues.

#761 of 772 Re: Engine Fluids Color and Rust questions [lhy] by ateixeira

Jun 08, 2009 (8:02 am)

Replying to: lhy (Jun 08, 2009 4:46 am)
I think those are red flags that ought to send you looking for another car.
 
The dirty transmission fluid could be flushed and refilled, but it's hard to say how much damage was already done.
 
Dirty engine oil may mean the prior owner didn't take the best care of the engine, too.
 
Add to that the rust, and the price suddenly seems high for a car that is well worn and has a lot of miles.
 
I'd shop elsewhere.

#762 of 772 Anyone ever used adaptive cruise control? by mortal1

Aug 13, 2009 (8:15 pm)

Hi, I may have asked this before, but does anyone here have a car with adaptive cruise control? I'd like to get your impressions as to whether it's really worth it or not.
 
The only cars that have it tend to be high priced luxury cars, and I'm not really sure I want to drop that much cash on a car. However, if it does truly make interstate and highway jogs so much easier, it may be worth it.

Messages Page 77 of 78

To POST a message, please Sign In.

Advertisement

Browse by Category

Browse by Vehicle
   View All Vehicles

Browse by Board
Browse by Topic
View All Topics

Edmunds Community

Advertisement