Ask the Car People.SM


Subaru Legacy Prices Paid and Buying Experience

1005 messages,  Last post on May 03, 2013 at 6:18 PM

You are in the Prices Paid - Buying & Leasing Experiences Forum.

What is this discussion about? Subaru Legacy, Sedan, Wagon

Messages Page 87 of 101

#860 of 1005 Re: CPO 2010 Limited 4cyl [kyoshi] by longislander1

Apr 03, 2011 (9:12 am)

Replying to: kyoshi (Apr 02, 2011 7:41 pm)
I don't mean to be critical, but since you asked, I think you would be overpaying for this car. You can probably buy the tint for less money from any local supplier and you can order the cargo tray at a discount off the factory price from many Subaru parts and accessory suppliers online. As for the spoiler, IMHO it doesn't belong on a 170-horsepower car. If you must have a Subaru, find a new one at that price or a little more. I would bet that the car you're looking at is a demonstrator or loaner and you simply don't know how it was treated. Ask the sales person for the Carfax on it.
 
I love my two '08 Subarus, including my Legacy Limited daily driver, but frankly, if I lived in Texas as you do, I would be driving a Hyundai Sonata Limited if I didn't need the all-wheel drive. The Hyundai is an all-around better car with a better warranty and, for your price range, you can probably find plenty of new ones in your area. Just my two cents.

#861 of 1005 Re: CPO 2010 Limited 4cyl [longislander1] by ateixeira

Apr 04, 2011 (6:14 pm)

Replying to: longislander1 (Apr 03, 2011 9:12 am)
My brother was car-shopping, so we just test drove a Kia Optima with a manual transmission.
 
To be honest, I was a bit disappointed. Fantastic car on paper, but some how it was just less than the sum of its parts. Numb steering, too-light clutch and shifter, not very fun to drive. Subjective things that are not shown on any spec sheet, but neither of us liked it.
 
We drove a Legacy sedan right afterwards and both of us liked it a lot better. Especially the steering.
 
He actually ended up buying a Forester.
 
I'd recommend the Kia only to someone who prefers isolation over driving involvement.

#862 of 1005 Re: CPO 2010 Limited 4cyl [ateixeira] by longislander1

Apr 05, 2011 (6:57 am)

Replying to: ateixeira (Apr 04, 2011 6:14 pm)
I know the Optima has shared mechanicals with the Sonata, but I haven't driven the Kia. From what I've seen, the Optima interior certainly looks cheaper than the Sonata's. I have driven the 2011 Legacy and have had several drives in the Sonata, both base trim (several days in a rental) and Limited. I'm a Subaru loyalist, but frankly, if you don't need the all-wheel-drive, the Sonata is the better car. It has more power, gets better mileage and has more amenities and a better warranty for the price. It is also better-looking and has a larger trunk. (Both have top safety ratings, although I don't know whether one is safer than the other.) Frankly, the Legacy looks and feels outdated by comparison. If Hyundai ever decides to make an AWD version, God help the Legacy. On a Legacy forum, I recently asked posters if they would buy another Legacy if they didn't need AWD. A lot of answers came back and the overwhelming majority said no. And now that Hyundai has released the 2.0 Turbo model with 274hp, you have to wonder about the relevance of the Legacy GT. My only concern with the Hyundai is whether I would get the same superb service that I now get at the Subaru dealer. The nearest Hyundai dealer to me has bad BBB ratings and many complaints.

#863 of 1005 Re: CPO 2010 Limited 4cyl [longislander1] by ateixeira

Apr 05, 2011 (9:45 am)

Replying to: longislander1 (Apr 05, 2011 6:57 am)
What was odd to me was that the Kia is supposed to be the sportier one. I can't imagine what the Sonata is like, then.
 
To be fair, most cars in this class are boring, with few exceptions. The Legacy was not, though.
 
Not to negate the positives about the Sonata, but the Optima also had poor rear visibility.
 
A Subaru without AWD is like non-alcoholic beer.
 
Hyundai's powertrain is great, but like I said, my complaints were in other areas, mostly subjective. 274hp with numb steering and isolated handling are not a good combination at all. They need a sporty version and a manual trans to boot.

#864 of 1005 Legacy 2.5i Premium w AWP by daniyal

Apr 25, 2011 (9:36 am)

I used this Forum before my purchase, so figured I give back.
 
I bought my Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium with All Weather Package for 21500 + 400 documentation fee. With TTL it was 24K. NYC area.

#865 of 1005 Re: CPO 2010 Limited 4cyl [ateixeira] by longislander1

Apr 25, 2011 (11:09 am)

Replying to: ateixeira (Apr 05, 2011 9:45 am)
Your comments probably point out the fact that two different people can have different reactions to the same car. It doesn't mean either one is wrong. I haven't driven the Kia, but I certainly found the Hyundai comparable in handling to my '08 Legacy Limited and the '11 Legacy Premium that was my last dealer loaner. At the NY auto show last week, I had a chance to do a close examination of the Sonata hybrid and that will probably be my next car. I'm willing to give up AWD for the better looks, extra luxury, additional room (interior and trunk) and superior gas mileage and warranties. If you put that hybrid next to a current Legacy, the latter simply looks old and out of date. I also had a chance to look at the new Impreza and, while it's better-looking than the last model, it's still a really boring design. Subaru may be selling well now and it's attempting to boost sales in warmer climates, but the competition is invading its territory. There are now more AWD choices and a number of other brands in the price range are matching its five-star crash ratings and exceeding its technology. Subaru was supposed to do a hybrid using Toyota technology, but we've heard nothing about that recently. It'll be offering Toyota's new small sports car, but it will be RWD and not AWD. It's getting a lot tougher to remain a Subaru loyalist when the brand isn't keeping up with the competition or maintaining its unique position in the market.

#866 of 1005 Re: CPO 2010 Limited 4cyl [longislander1] by ateixeira

Apr 26, 2011 (10:49 am)

Replying to: longislander1 (Apr 25, 2011 11:09 am)
Funny thing is I don't mind a conservative interior, in fact I'd prefer to take risks in exterior styling vs. a flashy interior where I can't find the buttons. To me ergonomics > styling.
 
Having said that, the Kia's interior was fine, in fact it sort of looked old school compared to Hyundai's edgier design.

#867 of 1005 Re: CPO 2010 Limited 4cyl [ateixeira] by longislander1

Apr 26, 2011 (11:36 am)

Replying to: ateixeira (Apr 26, 2011 10:49 am)
If I had my druthers, I'd like to see the Kia's exterior, the Hyundai's interior and the Subaru's AWD and safety, all in a hybrid. That would be my ideal car. BTW, I like the new Legacy's interior design a lot and it's a real improvement over my '08. It's the exterior that leaves me flat, both on the Legacy and (especially) the Outback. I'm guessing Subaru thinks it needs the conservative design to appeal to us quirky buyers, but we like good design, too.

#868 of 1005 Re: CPO 2010 Limited 4cyl [longislander1] by ateixeira

Apr 26, 2011 (12:57 pm)

Replying to: longislander1 (Apr 26, 2011 11:36 am)
I'll take the Hyundai warranty, the Kia price, and the Subaru vehicle! LOL
 
Maybe the Sonata's MPG as well....
 
 

#869 of 1005 2011 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium (Acton, MA) by amurray22

May 04, 2011 (8:07 am)

Have gotten good info from the fourm & wanted to give back. Here are the details of my recent purchase - 5/1/11
 
2011 Legacy Sedan 2.5i Premium
All weather package
Moonroof
Auto-dim mirror (dealer install)
Remote start (dealer install)
$24500, $25600 w/tax, registration and destination fees
Village Subaru - Acton MA
 
Thanks
Andy

Messages Page 87 of 101

To POST a message, please Sign In.

Advertisement

Browse by Category

Browse by Vehicle
   View All Vehicles

Browse by Board
Browse by Topic
View All Topics

Edmunds Community

Advertisement