Last post on Aug 24, 2013 at 6:00 PM
You are in the Kia Sedona
What is this discussion about?
Kia Sedona, Van
#4172 of 4592 Kia Sedona v. Toyota Sienna
Dec 30, 2004 (8:34 pm)
I posted this in another forum but thought this might be best, so here is the same info again. I need help in maiing my buying decision. Thanks.
I have an oportunity to buy a 2000 Toyota Sienna for $13,500 with approx. 53,800 miles, or a 2003 Sedona EX with leather seats, moon roof, etc., with only 15,000 miles for $13,900. My mechanic says buy the Toyota regardless of the mileage difference. What do you think?
The Sedona is much more luxurious, but the Toyota is much more sporty, and I think perhaps even has more room even though the Sedona looks larger.
The Sedona is actually sitting in my driveway now because the dealer insisted that I take it home to show my wife and to keep it overnight. I hate this kind of pressure but I finally gave in just so I could escape. I feel like I'm still waiting for the dealer to read my Miranda Rights to me.
Thanks for any input you can give me.
First time minivan shopper in Birmingham, AL
#4173 of 4592 Re: Kia Sedona v. Toyota Sienna [jingram105]
Dec 30, 2004 (8:41 pm)
Do you like the Sedona in your driveway? Does it drive nice? for that little money you cant go wrong.
If you plan to keep this Van for another 10 years I say go with the Toyota cause you can be assured it will be virtually trouble free.
'04 Sedona EX
#4174 of 4592 Re: Kia Sedona v. Toyota Sienna [craigmri]
Dec 31, 2004 (3:06 pm)
Thanks. We still have not made up our minds. I really want a low mileage Honda or Toyota but finding a reasonably priced one in Birmingham, AL is difficult. The dealer has now lowered the price of the KIA down to $13,500. Makes it hard to day no but I'm still not sold.
Thanks for your advice.
#4175 of 4592 Re: Kia Sedona v. Toyota Sienna [jingram105]
Dec 31, 2004 (11:00 pm)
Both are good vans. With the Sedona, you have the opportunity to get a better equipped, arguably more comfortable minivan that is newer and has lower mileage, for the same price. You give up the Toyota reputation for quality, which was somewhat stained with the hubbub about oil cooking in the 3.0L V6 engines of the past few years (I don't remember which years specifically).
There's still plenty of warranty on the Sedona; not so the Sienna.
Buying a 2003 for $13,500, you already have avoided the big depreciation hit on the Sedona; the original buyer has taken that hit for you!
In this comparison, several of the reasons that would typically be Sienna advantages have already been nullified.
Personally, I'd buy the Sedona because I think it is more vehicle at the same price. But the Sienna is a quality Toyota vehicle. It might come down to how much of the service history / previous life information is available on each van. That makes a difference to me.
Why are you still not sold on the Sedona? Is it something about this particular van, or just a general reluctance to buy a Kia? If you are still scared about Kia, you probably shouldn't buy one just on a leap of faith. If you conclude that Sedona does NOT represent a roll of the dice, then go for it. Personally, I think the posts on this board the past 3 years have shown the Sedona generally holds up fairly well. Some folks have problems with theirs, but overall Sedona seems to be holding its own vs. other minivans in quality/durability/reliability.
#4176 of 4592 Re: Kia Sedona v. Toyota Sienna [jingram105]
Jan 01, 2005 (9:14 am)
may i ask what dealership you are dealing with in b'ham,al? you may also want to consider that this dealer will try to sell you an extended warranty along with this vehicle(the toyota) thus jacking up the price and getting back whatever he thought he was giving away with the price. don't buckle under to pressure you won't get a good deal. do your research and negotiate on price not payment. i looked at the other vans and the prices drove me to look at a loaded sedona with an unmatched warranty in the industry so, i figured it to be a no brainer.
#4177 of 4592 Sedona Cargo Liner
Jan 03, 2005 (7:43 am)
The third row of seats is not needed in our empty nester household and I am looking for a cargo liner to cover from the back of the second row to the tailgate. They seem to be available for everything except the Sedona. Has anyone found a supplier or have suggestions?
#4178 of 4592 Re: Kia Sedona v. Toyota Sienna [jingram105]
Jan 05, 2005 (2:31 pm)
I too am from Birmingham, AL. I have had my 2004 Kia Sedona EX for... oh heck I'm not sure... I think about 6 months now. I bought it from Bill Byrd Kia over by the Galleria. I had what I felt was a good experience with them and compared to some of my other experiences around town with different brands I did not feel nearly as pressured. I have not had any work done on the van outside of 2 oil changes which I have had done for a very reasonable price at the dealership (under 20 bucks and it took about 30 minutes from pulling the lot to pulling out). My wife and I are really enjoying the van so far and it easily accomodates our 3 children.
Feel free to ask me quesitons.
#4179 of 4592 Does Rear distance sensor with sonar on 2003 model?
Jan 06, 2005 (4:07 pm)
Looking for a used van now. any one knows above question?
#4180 of 4592 2005 Sedona EX - Questions looking for answers
Jan 09, 2005 (7:19 pm)
Just bought a 2005 Sedona EX (500 km on it as I write this). Not knowing the car and never having owned a Kia I have questions I am hoping you as experienced owners can help with:
1) Anyone have a ticking sound from the engine on start? It seems to go away after awhile.
2)At idle and in gear I have two odd sounds that are very noticeable inside the van. One is the alternator (I know it's the alternator because the whine from it changes as I increase and decrease the load on it)and the noise comes from the right side of the engine. The second is a LOUD tranny pump coming from the left side of the engine (again the noise is noticeable when in gear but not in park or neutral). It's a chugging sort of noise.
3) The front suspension makes a "tock tock" sound when going over undulations in the road. Not when I do over real bumps, but something like a wave in the pavement. The car is fine over large bumps, handles well and feels tight otherwise.
4) Did your gas mileage get better after the engine was broken in (I hope)?
Thanks in advance for your help.
#4181 of 4592 Re: Sedona Cargo Liner [rhymexico]
Jan 09, 2005 (7:58 pm)
You can find mats for the sedona at mats4less.com. Husky liner makes custom fit mats for everything but he cargo area and Weatherall (weatherite?) makes a crgo liner for it. They are both sold at the site